Showing posts with label derwen services gwynedd council. Show all posts
Showing posts with label derwen services gwynedd council. Show all posts

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Documentary About An Autistic Child And Cyngor Gwynedd's Derwen Service Is A Hard Watch...

In June, 2025, Aled Gibbard, reported on Derwen, cyngor Gwynedd's service for disabled children as part of the Performance Report of the Children's Department. The report can be found in the agenda pack here -   
https://democracy.gwynedd.llyw.cymru/documents/g5531/Public%20reports%20pack%2012th-Jun-2025%2010.00%20Care%20Scrutiny%20Committee.pdf?T=10

David Lewis, is the leader of Derwen service, but Gibbard is the ultimate financial gatekeeper. Who though decides whether a child is 'disabled enough' to be supported by services?

Last years report gave little indication of the issues facing Derwen. 
Councillor Beth Lawton challenged the report that showed no real concerns with the service. 
Gibbard replied with “I’m not claiming that the way we’re reporting is completely accurate…” 

Councillor Gwynfor Owen asked the officers for the criteria that allows access to the disabled children’s service. He was told, a learning disability and those with a substantial delay. 

Owen also asked if access to Derwen services was dependant on IQ. Gibbard replied no… 
Some parents say this is exactly what they have been told by social workers.

Some families that have challenged the department and raised complaints find themselves subjected to parent blame and smears. This from the very services created to support them. 

Gibbard was present along with five other officers at a meeting where a Stage 2 Complaint investigator felt 'bullied' and 'overwhelmed' after she wrote a report highly critical of the children's department and its treatment of a disabled child and family. 

The report was only accepted by SS after four/five pages were deleted, who even then refused to accept the findings of the Independent Investigator and Independent Person.  

An 'assessment' by the department, undertaken after this complaint and a ruling from the Ombudsman for Wales, did not take into account that the child was autistic. 
Obviously, the child failed to meet the criteria. 

The social workers ended their report by writing that if anything was to happen it would be the fault of the parents. A complaint was raised but was not allowed to progress and eventually timed out...
                                                             
                                                                ********************

The documentary by Y Byd ar Bedwar shown on the 16th, November is upsetting.

Mae awdurdodau lleol yn methu darparu'r gofal sydd angen i blant ag anableddau. Nest Jenkins sy’n cwrdd â theuluoedd yng Ngwynedd sy’n wynebu'r posibilrwydd o anfon eu plant dros y ffin i Loegr i gael gofal, ac yn clywed gan gyn-weithwyr dan straen.
Translated - 
Local authorities are failing to provide the care children with disabilities need. Nest Jenkins meets families in Gwynedd who are facing the prospect of sending their children across the border to England for care, and hears from stressed former workers. 

The documentary is on YouTube and can be watched here -  

It is an uncomfortable watch.
A parent struggling with an autistic child is heart wrenching, worse when the interviewer is also attacked by the child.  For many parents, with autistic children, this is a daily occurrence - and lifelong.

It makes no sense that the child should be sent away to England, devoid of family support with carers who know nothing about the child and can't even speak his language.

An out of county residential placement for a child with such complex needs will cost the Local Authority many thousands of pounds a week.
Surely, it would be much better if a child is supported to stay in their local area and much cheaper for the council.

The programme makers report that in the last three years over half the staff have left and that the vacant posts have not been filled by equally qualified people. 
The number of social workers and senior social workers has fallen from 9 to 4, and social care practitioners now do much of their work.  

Just as shocking is that former workers will not speak directly on camera. 
Instead their identity and voice is disguised. 
Why are the workers frightened of speaking out - even after leaving the council?
Fear of reprisals..?

Cyngor Gwynedd refused to take part in the programme.
As did Mabon ap Gwynfor, the Welsh health minister, after initially saying he would. 

Perhaps Dafydd Gibbard, the council's CEO could ask Aled Gibbard for an explanation?
And then make a public statement.

Something is very, very wrong within Gwynedd council... 

 

 


Saturday, 21 February 2026

Low Hanging Fruit - Cyngor Gwynedd Council...

Surrey County Council has been accused of carrying out "illegal" and "immoral" care assessments of vulnerable adults, and excluding their families, in a bid to save money by reducing their support.

Learning disabled adults face 'dangerous' cuts to care after 'illegal assessments', claim families.
https://www.itv.com/news/2026-02-12/learning-disabled-adults-face-care-cuts-after-unsafe-assessments-say-families

In response, Sinead Mooney, Surrey County Council’s Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care said - 
We’ve just approved an adult social care budget increase of more than £27million.

 
Cyngor Gwynedd have been faking assessments on vulnerable adults and children - for years.
An Ombudsman for Wales report from 2018 -
https://www.lukeclements.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Ombudsman-Gwynedd-Council-report-201700388.pdf 

 Using a person's disability against them..?

 

Low hanging fruit..? 

Untrained social workers sent out to remove services from vulnerable people by untrained senior social workers - simply to save money. 
The PSOW was so enraged it included the case in its hall of shame casebook on human rights -
https://www.ombudsman.wales/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/104483-Equality-and-Human-Rights-Casebook_Eng_v03.pdf

The then cabinet member for adults, Dafydd Meurig, should have presented this case to the care scrutiny committee who could have called for an investigation/review of the department.
Meurig did not...

Ombudsman recommendations...
This case is even more appalling when it was discovered that Gwynedd council had lied to the PSOW by saying that specific staff training had taken place when it had not.

Gwynedd council target children too...
A social worker undertook an assessment on a disabled, autistic child but did not tick the disabled box. This excluded the child from support by Derwen, cyngor Gwynedd's service for disabled children.
An Ombudsman's investigation found that the assessment was 'predetermined to fail'...

On the recommendation from the Ombudsman, another assessment was undertaken...
This time a social worker from the 16+ team, Sharon Keys and Barry John Thomas, a social worker/complaints officer from Derwen assessed the child.

Both social workers said they knew nothing about the PSOW ordering the re-assessment and declined the report when offered it. They said they weren't looking back, but 'taking it from today'.

Incredibly, the social workers said they would not be considering the child's autism for the purpose of the assessment... 

Parent bashing... 
It was no surprise that the second assessment also denied support for the child.
Instead, the social workers used the 'assessment' to parent blame.

Complaint shut down...
A stage 2 complaint was raised against the social workers assessment.
It was not allowed to progress and was eventually timed out.

Protect the senior officers...?
Emails indicate that the investigating officer and the independent person may have not been as 'independent' as they should.The emails also suggest that Gwynedd's senior complaints manager was more active in the 'independent' investigation than perhaps he should have been. 

Both Surrey and Gwynedd councils have been caught faking assessments on vulnerable people.
Whilst Surrey are unlikely to be repeat offenders - Gwynedd council certainly are...

Something is so very wrong within Gwynedd council...





 

 

 

Sunday, 29 June 2025

Cyngor Gwynedd Council - "I'm not claiming that the way we're reporting is completely accurate..."

Cyngor Gwynedd  held an Education and Economy Scrutiny Committee meeting on Thursday, 19th June 2025. The webcast of the meeting can be found here -
https://gwynedd.public-i.tv/core/portal/webcast_interactive/993870

The Task and Finish Group recommendations for Gwynedd council's Draft Education Language Policy - Cyngor Gwynedd Language Strategy 2023 - 2033 were discussed. There has been a recent push by councillors for schools to be taught through the medium of Welsh only...

The recommendations can be found in the agenda pack here -
https://democracy.gwynedd.llyw.cymru//documents/g5496/Public%20reports%20pack%2019th-Jun-2025%2010.30%20Education%20and%20Economy%20Scrutiny%20Committee.pdf?T=10

On the 16th June, the Planning Commiittee held a meeting. That webcast can be found here - 
https://gwynedd.public-i.tv/core/portal/webcast_interactive/992005

The meeting discussed an application for an 'affordable self build' house in Penygroes. It has been refused in the past but the local councillor called it in for a debate. The councillor did not attend the meeting...
The recommendation was to refuse with the department citing three reasons including a lack of communication with the applicant. For reasons unknown some councillors wished to support the application anyway. The application was refused... 

Gwynedd's Care Scrutiny Committee met on Thursday, 12th June 2025.
The webcast can be found here - 
https://gwynedd.public-i.tv/core/portal/webcast_interactive/991166

A performance report from the head of Housing and Property department, Carys Fôn Williams, was presented. 

Next up was the performance report of the children and supporting families department, presented by cabinet member, Menna Trenholme.
With Marian Parry Hughes absent from work, it was left to the interim heads, Aled Gibbard and Sharron Carter Williams, to answer members questions. 

The department's report makes no mention of the absences of two of its most senior officers and not one scrutiny member raised concerns. 

Morfa Bychan was discussed. The children's home should have been open last year. and whilst children have been placed there, the home is still not registered...

Councillor Beth Lawton raised concerns that according to the graphics in the report the interim heads had no concerns with the department at all. Lawton pointed out that there were concerns and described the Derwen service and its workload as huge.
Gibbard replied "I'm not claiming that the way we're reporting is completely accurate..." 

Councillor Gwynfor Owen asked the officers for the criteria that allows access to the disabled children's service. He was told, a learning disability and those with a substantial delay. Owen also asked if access to Derwen services was dependant on IQ. Gibbard replied no... 
Some parents have been told exactly that...

 
The Derwen criteria has been called out as unlawful in the past and in 2019, the Ombudsman for Wales recommendation was - 
The Council should review its Derwen policy to ensure its criteria aligns with the Social Services and Wellbeing (Wales) Act 2014 and the Equality Act 2010’s definition of ‘disability’, and ensure staff are informed about any changes (within three months). 

What of the Hugh Morgan Autism Review? 
Have his recommendations been implemented? Perhaps Mr Morgan could be asked for his thoughts on 'progress' since his review?
His review can be found here -
https://gwyneddsfailingcouncil.blogspot.com/2021/04/finally-gwynedd-councils-autism-report.html

Moving on, the report states that the purpose of the performance report is 'to present the performance of the Children and Supporting Families Department over the past year.'

But then states 'the report has been created based on the information and content of the latest meeting to challenge and support the performance of the Children and Supporting Families Department with the Director, the Senior Operational Officer and myself present at this meeting.'

So not over the past year? Only since the 'latest meeting' - whenever that was...?

The performance report for the Adults SS was also presented.

For what they're worth the reports can be found in the agenda pack here - 
https://democracy.gwynedd.llyw.cymru//documents/g5531/Public%20reports%20pack%2012th-Jun-2025%2010.00%20Care%20Scrutiny%20Committee.pdf?T=10

In other news, Cyngor Gwynedd is advertising for a Corporate Director.
https://www.gwynedd.llyw.cymru/en/Council/Jobs-and-Careers/Corporate-Director.aspx

Something is very wrong within Gwynedd council...
 

 

 

 

 







 

 

 

 



 





Tuesday, 31 January 2023

PSOW 'Variances' To Recommendations Made And Remits For Investigations...

Accepting the Ombudsman for Wales offer of a third investigation into cyngor Gwynedd was a mistake.

Yet again, the 'remit' for investigation was a bone of contention.
So much evidence of continued bad behaviour by officers was not to be investigated, nor action taken over non compliance as the Ombudsman had signed this off as completed - when it was not. Farcical.

A reminder that the child's diagnosis of autism was repeatedly ignored by Gwynedd's Derwen manager and was not allowed to be taken into account by social workers in either care assessment. Social workers said that they had not accessed and read the the child's files and were not interested in the family history, preferring they said to 'take it from here'. The second care assessment carried out on the orders of the Ombudsman appeared to morph into a safeguarding issue of a neurotypical child and an exercise in parent bashing...

The Ombudsman appeared not to take full regard of the child's diagnosis of autism either and when challenged by the family who cited another case for comparison, the Ombudsman warned that cases should not be compared. Of course not, but the fact remains one child's diagnosis appeared to be treated differently from another.

Reading through past investigation reports and FOI's to both organisations reveal council officers who apologise, sometimes even sincerely, and then ignore agreements made. The Ombudsman's acceptance of variances to its recommendations without complainants knowledge is also insulting after such lengthy and costly investigations. 

The Ombudsman then submitted its preferred 'remit' to cyngor Gwynedd without the complainant's approval or knowledge. The complainants were not happy and a 'pause' to the complaint was asked of the Ombudsman while a Subject Access Request was submitted to its information office seeking its correspondence with the council. The Ombudsman agreed to the delay...

A SAR had also been submitted to cyngor Gwynedd and whilst the council's Information office had dealt fairly with previous requests, it now produced pages of censored content...

Part of an email thread does show officers discussing waylaying the child at their place of education - without parents knowledge. Would this be an attempt to get the child to agree to something so the third investigation could be halted? The same council officers who have a history of fake assessments, interference in investigations, bullying staff and writing reports in spite of the evidence and an autistic child with complex issues. How desperate were senior officers to even contemplate this...?

A reminder that Gwynedd SS department had been investigated previously by the Ombudsman and hauled over the coals for similar tactics in the case of an autistic man in residential care who had their services removed. The case involved officers speaking with the man alone without family members or support. Using a person's disability against them...?

As usual, the SS department apologised for their behaviour but recommendations from this case were also not complied with though the Ombudsman has signed this off as completed albeit with another variance. Extra training in ASD for staff was accepted by the Ombudsman instead of the required review of services. There is no public record of this training or how many attended...

The Ombudsman's Information office did comply with part of the SAR but did not release documentation between themselves and the council adding further doubt to the impartiality of the Ombudsman.

Cyngor Gwynedd. who had released dialogue between the Ombudsman in a previous case now refused. An internal review was requested where the reviewing officer claimed that the Ombudsman had discussion with the council to not disclose information in this case. For obvious reasons, the officer was not believed and challenged to provide the evidence. The letter from the Ombudsman to the council was released to the family...

The Ombudsman is independent, impartial and fair - it says that on its website, nor does it advise either party. 

When challenged, the Ombudsman explained that the correspondence was not 'advice' but merely their response to a council's query. The response was very detailed and information passed between the two organisations in how the council deal with the SAR, for 'transparency' and 'consistency' as the Ombudsman advised. A reminder that the Ombudsman was not the data controller in this instance...

During this time, the Ombudsman had become impatient and demanded a decision be made to accept the 'remit' or the complaint would be closed. The 'remit' was not accepted by the complainants and the Ombudsman closed the case.

Something is very wrong with the complaints process in Wales...


 





 


Monday, 31 January 2022

Cyngor Gwynedd Council - More Questions Re Compliance - Ombudsman.

The Ombudsman for Wales email of the 23rd, December, 2021, also mentions Derwen, Cyngor Gwynedd council's disabled children's service and states -

 
"The consultant’s review considered the role of Derwen (responsible for assessments of children) and of NEWIAS (with a remit for accessing adult diagnostic assessment) and the chart within the draft plan seen demonstrates how the agencies will work together.  The need in particular for a transitional social worker and additional training for relevant officers was identified and is to be implemented as well as establishing an Autism champion."


What draft plan? 

Gwynedd council and Derwen should have been working with agencies since 2008 and the introduction of the Autism SAP. How can they plan to work with agencies that they have been working with for the past 14 years?

With regard to an autism champion the Plaid Cymru Councillor for Glyder in Bangor, Elin Walker Jones, was the nominated autism champion from 2012 and was even nominated for an award in 2014 - she didn't win. What happened to her? 


The 'additional training' the Ombudsman mentions should have already taken place (details below)

 

It would be interesting to have sight of the evidence provided to Hugh Morgan's Review by Gwynedd senior management - and fact checked.


The SS departments these officers manage and their actions and behaviours have been heavily criticised in five Ombudsman investigations . Four of those investigations involved the bad treatment meted out to those on the autistic spectrum. their families and even complaint investigators. One investigation - not autism related - was because of a death in a local care home.

 

Have the Ombudsman's recommendations from that case been complied with? The council's last CEO, Dilwyn Williams, warned the adult SS department that the work was long overdue before he retired. Where is evidence of compliance? 


Hugh Morgan's review and recommendations that senior officers have accepted but also failed to implement can be found here -
https://gwyneddsfailingcouncil.blogspot.com/2021/04/finally-gwynedd-councils-autism-report.html

 


But why is Mr Morgan raising issues with the Derwen 'criteria'...?
The council were meant to have already updated their Derwen criteria to align with law from a previous investigation - the Ombudsman has signed this off as completed. It makes no sense....

Also this from an Ombudsman's investigation which the council accepted in 2018 -


What is the point of costly and time consuming reviews and investigations when nothing changes?

Something is very wrong within Gwynedd council...